SUPPLEMENTARY REPORT BY C-10 PERMANENT REPRESENTATIVES
TO THE UN ON SECURITY COUNCIL REFORM
INTRODUCTION
1.
This supplementary report is submitted pursuant to Paragraph 6 of the report of
the C-10 Permanent Representatives to the UN on Security Council Reform, already
submitted to H.E. President Ernest Bai Koroma of Sierra Leone, the Coordinator of the
African Union Committee of Ten on UN Reform.
It seeks to reflect the situation
following the release of the report of the President of the General Assembly’s Task
Force on the Question of Equitable Representation on and Increase in the Membership
of the Security Council on 9 June 2008. The PGA’s report gives an analysis of the
current situation of the reform process, especially the positions of the various
stakeholders, many of which are already in our original report. This report therefore
concentrates on areas that are either not covered in our original report, or elaborates
further areas that are already covered by it. The report is concluded with some
observations that the Committee may wish to consider in their deliberations.
THE CURRENT SITUATION AS PRESENTED IN THE REPORT OF THE
TASKFORCE
2.
The following are the major elements of the current situation as presented by the
Report of the Task Force:
1. There is sustained general understanding that the Security Council needs
to be reformed in its composition as well as working methods to reflect
“international reality”, democratic representation and to enhance the
participation of small and developing countries;
2. The positions of major groupings described in the report remain
unchanged. It would be noted that positions of other groupings are
consistent with the African demand for two permanent seats, but remain
silent on the question of the veto;
3. There is an observable attempt to push for the proposed transitional
approach which aims at achieving reviewable compromise after a
stipulated period of operation, while members still retain their original
positions. The provisions of this proposal are:
-
Extended seats that could be allocated for the full duration of the
intermediary arrangement, including the possibility of recall;
-
Extended seats, which would be for a longer period than the regular
two years term, but with the possibility of re-election. The length of the